
Store brands took 21.3% of the consumer packaged goods dollars Circana tracks across U.S. retail in 2025, up from 19.1% in 2021, according to PLMA and Circana (reported). At the Wegmans I walked, the store's own seltzer filled one or two full shelves of the beverage aisle (observed).
What I did. I walked the beverage aisle at a Wegmans, a Price Chopper and a Target, looking at facings and which brands get the largest share of the shelf.
What I found
At Wegmans, the biggest block of seltzer space went to Wegmans' own private label brand, which took up one or two full shelves (observed).
At Price Chopper, the shelf went mostly to large national brands. The aisle was heavy on soda and lighter on seltzer. In the seltzer section I filmed, the shelf tags on Polar Seltzer 6-packs showed a regular price of $3.99, or 2 for $7 on sale (observed).
At Target, the category had less shelf space overall, but the space was much more fragmented, mostly across trendy or niche brands (observed).
Store brand beverages grew dollar sales 4.8% and unit sales 2.3% in 2025. Across all categories, store brand dollar sales grew 3.3% while national brands grew 1.2% (reported, PLMA and Circana).
In the second week of November, I had more calls with brands that urgently need to tie velocity to specific marketing activities. Two brand leaders told me some version of the same thing: "We've used every platform and can't find a way to confidently, clearly show exactly if and why our marketing is working on the shelf." (reported)
Why it happens
You'll hear that private label is taking over the shelf and national brands are done. In reality, national brands still sold more than $1 trillion in 2025 and grew 1.2%, so they are being disrupted, not wiped out. On the other side, you'll hear that if a brand spends enough on marketing, the shelf will follow. Marketing can move product, and that part is true. But each of these three retailers is building its shelf for a different shopper, and in every case the retailer decides who earns the space. A store brand starts with the retailer on its side. Every other brand has to earn its facings with velocity it can show, and that is exactly what those two brand leaders told me they can't do.
Look at how many handoffs sit between a marketing dollar and a facing. An ad runs. A shopper sees it. That shopper walks into one specific store. The product has to be in that store's set, at a price the shopper accepts. The shopper buys it. That sale shows up in the retailer's data at the store level. Then a buyer looks at velocity for the whole category before deciding who gets more space, who keeps it and who loses it. If you can't connect the first step to the last one, you're asking for shelf space on faith, and the store brand next to you doesn't have to.
What I'd do
Walk your own set at three different kinds of retailers this week, the way I did. Count your facings, the store brand's facings and your largest competitor's, and write down the shelf price and any promo tag.
Before your next marketing push, pick a defined group of stores and write down your unit velocity there for the weeks before it starts. Run the activity, then compare the same stores afterward. A number you measured before you spent is defensible and proven. A number you modeled afterward isn't.
Bring that before-and-after to your buyer or broker on one page, store by store, ahead of your next review.
The ask
If you have facings counts or store brand share for your category at a specific retailer, reply and send it. I'll credit you by name, or describe you however you prefer, in a future report.
This is the first Field Report. Every Tuesday I'll send one thing I went and saw, on a shelf, on a call with a buyer or broker, or in the numbers, with the mechanics explained plainly and fixes you can use that week. Every number is labeled observed (I saw it), reported (someone told me or published it) or modeled (my estimate).
Source: PLMA, "U.S. Private Label Industry Reached $282.8 Billion in Sales in 2025," Circana Unify+ data for the 52 weeks ending Dec. 28, 2025.

