Polar Seltzer got me to try its winter flavors with one can at a party. Then it lost the second purchase, because I couldn't find that can in any store where I shop.

That's worth paying attention to, because Polar is very good at the first half. When it signed its national distribution deal with Keurig Dr Pepper in 2020, it was sold in less than 35% of the country and said it was the fastest-turning sparkling water wherever it was sold (reported, from the companies' joint announcement).

What I did

I had Polar's winter cans at a party, including Blood Orange Cranberry and Lingonberry Citrus. I liked them enough to go looking for them at the stores where I shop, and then I checked online to see where I was supposed to buy them.

What I found

  1. The only winter flavor I could find in a store was in large plastic bottles. The slim cans I had at the party weren't there (observed).

  2. The cans do exist. Target's site lists a 12-pack winter variety pack in cans, and BJ's lists a 24-pack (checked online, Nov 11).

  3. These flavors come back on purpose. Last winter Polar brought back Blood Orange Cranberry alongside three new flavors (reported, MassLive).

  4. Polar has been doing this for a long time. People have been hunting for its one-time flavors since Unicorn Kisses in March 2016 (reported, Boston Globe).

Why it happens

To be clear, this isn't a knock on Polar. People love this brand, and the limited editions clearly work. The point is that getting someone to try a product and getting them to buy it again are two different jobs.

A limited edition is built for the first job. It gives people a reason to try something new, and it creates a little urgency. The second job depends on things the brand doesn't fully control: which packs each store decides to carry, how much it orders, and whether the shelf gets restocked before the season ends. So a person who fell for a slim can at a party can walk into a store and only find a big bottle, or nothing at all. At that point the brand has paid for the trial and lost the repeat.

What I'd do

  1. Put a way to find it on the pack. A QR code that goes to a store finder or the online variety pack lets the person who just tried it buy it again that day.

  2. Make sure it’s stocked on Amazon. It’s the default when someone can’t find in store. I looked and found some flacors, but no Lingonberry :(

  3. Capture the people who want more. A signup on the brand site that says "tell me when it's back" turns a one-time fan into a customer you can reach next season.

  4. Track repeat separately from trial for every limited flavor. That's how you find out whether a seasonal is building the brand or just borrowing attention for a few weeks.

Your turn

If you run a seasonal or limited-edition line, how do you track whether the people who tried it ever bought it again? Reply to this email. I'd like to hear what's working, and I'll share the best answers next week.

John

Sources

Reply

Avatar

or to participate